The three things they're judging, and none of them is your wardrobe
Executive presence is the sort of feedback people give you without ever writing it down. You hear that you need more of it, no one can explain what it looks like, and before long you are second-guessing your blazer. Pause there. The people evaluating it are weighing three things: whether they can trust you with a decision, whether your voice registers when you speak, and whether you hold your composure when things go sideways. Your wardrobe is not on that list. The fuzziness isn't random, either. Research on the likability penalty has repeatedly shown that the same request is heard as assertive from a man and as demanding from a woman, and "presence" is a convenient place for that bias to hide.
The verification
Looking back across the past month, would you say yes or no to each item? Tally only the moments that actually occurred, leaving aside the ones you merely wish had gone differently.
1st Whenever you offer a recommendation, lead with the bottom line and follow it with the rationale.
2nd In a meeting, you voiced disagreement with someone above you, and you did it aloud.
3rd You can summarize your team's mission in a single sentence that someone from outside would immediately understand.
4th When something goes wrong, colleagues bring it to you first instead of bypassing you.
5th In Columbus conference rooms, you allow silence to stretch out rather than hurrying to break it.
6th You told the group, "I don't have that answer yet, but I'll get it to you by Thursday," and you followed through.
7th The messages you send to senior leaders run briefer than the ones they send back to you.
8th When a senior colleague asked for something you couldn't provide, you declined and explained why in one sentence.
9th You appeared calm in a room that clearly wasn't.
Point ten. At a Westerville planning session weeks later, a colleague gave back one of your expressions word for word.
Reading your score
Eight to ten: excellent. People in the room already regard you as a person who decides things. If you still keep getting the feedback, ask who is offering it and what they really mean, because it may have little to do with you.
Four to seven: developing. You possess the judgment, and you already give off some of the signal. The gap comes down mainly to speed and brevity: leading with the recommendation, sending the shorter note, and letting the silence stand while others catch up.
Scores of zero to three: capable yet restrained. You are producing the work while leaving others to determine what it amounts to. That is not a defect in your character. Many of us were trained to show our reasoning before earning the conclusion, which is good advice for a classroom but not for a boardroom in the Columbus Region.
What to do next
With a score of eight to ten, the next time someone brings up "presence," ask, "What exactly would you like to see differently in the next meeting?" and jot down the response. If nobody can name anything specific, you have discovered something about the feedback itself rather than about yourself.
With a score of four to seven, spend the next month opening every update with the decision you need in its first sentence. Change nothing else. Notice how the room responds.
With a score of zero to three, at your next meeting in Columbus or wherever it falls, state one brief disagreement with the most senior person present, then stop speaking. One sentence is enough: "I see it differently, and here's why." Let them respond. The quiet that follows is where the presence lives.
Count your yeses, then forward this to the woman who was told she needs more presence and never told what that meant.